239-241 Hurleyville Main Street

Hurleyville, NY12747

A Rare Opportunity: Charming Victorian Home with 3 Income Potential – Hurleyville, NY. Imagine owning a beautiful early 1800s Victorian home brimming with character, and a world of possibilities for income and lifestyle. This exceptional property in the heart of Hurleyville, Sullivan County, offers just that – a unique chance to create a truly versatile property. Spanning over 4,000 square feet across total units, this property is designed for flexibility. The main residence, a charming 2,300+ square foot Victorian country home, currently functions as a spacious 4 bedroom, 2 bathroom single-family dwelling. However, it boasts a history as a legal two-family home and can easily be converted back to provide immediate rental income. Picture yourself enjoying comfortable living while benefiting from passive income! But the opportunities don’t stop there. A remarkable 1,800+ square foot insulated accessory building awaits your vision. Currently framed and ready for completion (with recent approval for third unit!), this expansive 24x40 space presents endless potential – from a lucrative third rental unit to an inspiring artist's studio, workshop, or even a small home business headquarters. Equipped with electric, plumbing, and even a convenient half-bath, it’s truly a blank canvas waiting to be brought to life. Plus the convenience of two standard access doors and a garage door adds to its versatility. Beyond the buildings themselves, this property benefits from commercial water and sewer connections - a valuable asset. The home also has an attached garage that provides additional storage or could be transformed into bonus living space. Location is Key: Nestled in vibrant Hurleyville, you'll find yourself steps away from Main Street shops, the Rails to Trails perfect for scenic walks or bike rides, steps away from the Hurleyville Performing Arts Center and movie theater—and delightful local shops, restaurants & Sullivan County Museum. Sullivan County's rich offerings include RW Catskills Casino and Kartrite Waterpark to tranquil lakes offering fishing and water activities. Many wineries and breweries and distilleries add even more flavor to the local scene! A Lifestyle Within Reach: This isn't just about property; it's about lifestyle. Enjoy the peace of country living with all the conveniences nearby – a world away in terms of peace and quiet but close enough for weekend trips or commuting if needed all just 90 minutes from New York City! Whether you envision creating generational wealth through multiple rental streams or simply enjoying a spacious family home with room to pursue your passions, this property offers something truly special. A chance to create something special - whether it’s a multi-generational family compound ("mother-daughter" setup on the wraparound porch sounds idyllic!), an income-generating investment or your dream creative workspace...Bring your vision and let's get started! Bring your imagination and design flair – This isn’t just a property; it's an opportunity!

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Hudson Valley [email protected]


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2025-05-17 01:59 PM EDT. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.